In today’s edition of He Said / She Said, we examine the relative pros and cons of using the MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher as a primary home defense weapon. Much has been said about the merits of pistols, revolvers, shotguns, and AR platform rifles for home defense, but little serious consideration has been given to suitability of larger and more powerful crew-served weapons.
First, some basic specifications:
- 350 round per minute cyclic rate
- 40 x 53mm high-explosive grenade rounds
- ‘Moderate’ stopping power
- Tripod and vehicle mount options
|I’ve been looking into other options for our primary home defense gun. I’m thinking we need something crew-served – like the MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher.|
|Hmmm. Not bad. I like the stopping power, but you do realize it has an effective blast radius of about 15 meters right? That’s way bigger than our family room.
I think the collateral damage might be a bit excessive. And we just got a new wide screen TV, remember?
|Yeah but at least we wouldn’t have to worry about complex things like range estimation. I think it would be pretty much point and shoot since it would be indoors.|
|Ummm. Have you considered that the MK19 grenades require at least 30 meters of flight time to arm? Our hallway is definitely not that long.|
|Well, we have been talking about getting a bigger house. Why not kill two birds with one grenade, so to speak? Maybe we can design in a longer hallway to the master bedroom and a larger family room at the other end to contain the blast radius.|
|I’m not sure that we can count on bad guys only breaking in through the main hallway. What if someone tries to come in through a window? Have you thought of that?|
|But honey, those rounds will penetrate up to 2 inches of rolled armor! Awesome!|
|Right. Have you even thought about ammo costs? We certainly don’t have room in our budget for 40x53mm high explosive rounds, or even practice rounds for that matter.
And last time I looked, you don’t have reloading dies for the MK19…
|No problem, I’ll check and see if Midway USA has some!|
|And last I checked, the tripod mount only comes in black. And you know I’ve been wanting to re-do the master bedroom in a tangerine, turquoise, and aubergine palette.
I do like the vehicle mount option though. I would feel a lot safer on those long drives to Florida…
|So what do you think, is it a plan?|
|How about let’s talk after you get me my new computer and come up with an extra 20 grand?|
Depending on the size of your property, I would like to propose an alternative. There is a choice that would not completely sacrifice manueverability and provide ample stopping power. Also, you would gain the advantage of using indirect fire. The 81mm mortar weighs in under 100 lbs. In addition to indirect fire you would have additional ammo options with white and red phospherous and illumination. (A great help for any low light situations that could develop in your backyard)
Being a person with an irrational fetish, errr, overriding love for the 20mm M163 Vulcan Air Defense System, I approve and applaud this attempt to make the “peace dividend” a bit more personal than just a few random airbase shutdowns and cheap surplus BDU’s.
But what does a Mk19 offer you that a few well-placed Claymores don’t?
Aside from full-auto, that is.
I hadn’t considered the Vulcan system. And that’s fully automated as I recall, which could be a plus for late night intrusions…
[…] Grenade Salt & Pepper Shakers from Top Notch Tactical. This one would complement Dad’s MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher nicely! Claymore Mine Hitch […]
You might want to try the automatic perimeter defense guns from the extended version of “Aliens” which can target, track, and splatter aliens
Since it is works on them, I would think zombies and home-invasion gremlins would be vulnerable.
[…] a novel concealed carry option.Tom: Our editorial staff has had a raging debate over whether the MK-19 Automatic Grenade Launcher is appropriate for home defense. As a former Military guy and multi-gun competitor, can you please weigh in on this and settle the […]
[…] everything. you just won’t cut it.My Gun Culture: Recently we had an editorial examining whether the MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher was appropriate for home defense. Would the experts of the Brownells Gun Tech team like to weigh in on this?Dave: I don’t know […]
[…] Gun Culture: Recently we had an editorial examining whether a MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher was suitable for home defense. Would a experts of a Brownells Gun Tech group like to import in on […]
[…] I’m trying to convince my wife that the Mk 46 will make an excellent home defense gun. […]
[…] a respected self-defense expert, I think you might have some great insight on this question. Is the MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher appropriate for home defense? Obviously a drawback is shrapnel damage to our home, and probably […]
[…] We ask all of our guests the same very important question. What’s your opinion on using an MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher for home defense? My wife and I are still arguing about this. She’s concerned about collateral damage to the […]
Loaded up with multiple projectile rounds, this would be a good Home Defense choice.
Besides, all you would have to do is pull back on the charging handle and the bad guys will run from the house right?
[…] Because the MK-19 Automatic Grenade Launcher is too […]
[…] MGC: We ask everybody to weigh in and solve a long standing debate question. Do you think that an MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher is appropriate for home defense? […]
[…] can settle a long-standing debate. My wife and I have been arguing over the best home-defense gun. I think it’s an MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher, but she’s worried about the blast radius and collateral damage. What say you? Settle this for […]
[…] if you have a backpack, briefcase, camera bag, medical kit, bug out bag or MK-19 Automatic Grenade Launcher case with all these MOLLE straps, then maybe you’ve tried to hook some other pouch, canteen […]
[…] days and showed up with rifles on the backs, a pistol or twelve and perhaps a couple of MK-19 automatic grenade launchers. Because Starbucks would be thrilled to have the Internet Ninja Militia show up in their stores, […]
torrentz.com not working
Is The MK19 Automatic Grenade Launcher Appropriate For Home Defense?