My Gun Culture

Guns, Shooting Tips, Ammo, Concealed Carry & Gear. Who's bringing the chips?

  • Store
  • Cart
  • Guns
    • Handguns
    • Rifles
    • Shotguns
  • Ammo
  • Shooting Gear
    • Optics, Sights and Lasers
    • Holsters
    • Accessories
    • Reloading
  • Shooting Tips
    • Competitive Shooting
    • Concealed Carry
    • General Tips
    • Gun Maintenance & Customization
    • Gun Safety
    • Home Defense
    • Reloading
  • News
    • 2nd Amendment
    • Business
    • Competition
    • Crime
    • Politics
    • NRA Annual Meeting
    • SHOT Show
  • Opinion
  • Reviews
    • Ammunition Reviews
    • Book Reviews
    • Clothing Bling Reviews
    • Gun Accessories Reviews
    • Gun Reviews
    • Holster Reviews
    • Optics and Sights Reviews
    • Reloading Equipment Reviews
  • Half-Cocked
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Shooting Tips / Home Defense / What’s Best For Home Defense? Pistol, Rifle or Shotgun?

What’s Best For Home Defense? Pistol, Rifle or Shotgun?

April 16, 2015 By Tom McHale 1 Comment

A short-barrel carbine like this Beretta ARX 100 makes an excellent home defense weapon. It's compact, yet far more powerful than a handgun.

A short-barrel carbine like this Beretta ARX 100 makes an excellent home defense weapon. It’s compact, yet far more powerful than a handgun.

I just had a wonderful opportunity to directly compare pros and cons of different guns (or weapons systems as my instructors say) for home defense.

You see, I just (barely) graduated from Tactical Pre-School. They were threatening to have me repeat, but I don’t think any of the instructors wanted me back for another session.

My tactical pre-school took place at the Academi training facility in Moyock, North Carolina. The folks at Beretta Defense Technologies hosted the event as a way to give some of us pre-schooler tactical folks proper exposure to a variety of Beretta tactical guns.  Sprawled out over 7,000 acres just south of Norfolk, Virginia, it covers all the tactical subjects for pre-schoolers to doctoral studies. With 25 live ranges, an airstrip, multiple offensive and defensive driving tracks, and several explosives ranges, it’s got everything. Heck, just sitting the mess hall trying to match uniforms to special forces teams of various allied countries is entertaining, and just a little bit scary.

Anyway, this is all relevant because my tactical arts and crafts training covered four primary tactical disciplines: pistol, carbine, shotgun and long-range precision rifle. All, well most, of these are pretty darn applicable to home defense. Long-range precision rifle might be a stretch unless you have a reciprocal agreement with a neighbor to set up sniper overwatch hides. My neighbors suck at long range precision shooting, so that plan is out for me as I would have to carry the load. The class was a great opportunity to spend a couple of days contemplating the relative pros and cons of using a pistol, rifle or shotgun as my primary home defense platform.

To be clear, our abbreviated training focused solely on fighting with these respective platforms. I learned a lot about each, but just as importantly, the quality side-by-side training time got me thinking.

Let’s take a look at some of the pros and cons of each platform.

Read more at AmmoLand!

Filed Under: Home Defense, Shooting Tips Tagged With: Beretta, federal, Federal Premium, home defense

Comments

  1. Roger V. Tranfaglia says

    April 16, 2015 at 12:04 pm

    Another good read…THANK YOU!

    Reply

Got something to say? Cancel reply

Legal disclosures about our review policies.

the Constitution - A Revolutionary Story

Follow My Gun Culture

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • Linkedin
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter

Check out our books

  • Sale! The Practical Guide to Reloading Ammunition

    The Practical Guide to Reloading Ammunition

    $16.97 $14.95
    Add to cart
  • Sale! The Practical Guide to Gun Holsters for Concealed Carry

    The Practical Guide to Gun Holsters for Concealed Carry

    $16.99 $12.99
    Read more
  • Sale! The Practical Guide to Guns and Shooting, Handgun Edition

    The Practical Guide to Guns and Shooting, Handgun Edition

    $16.99 $12.75
    Add to cart
  • Sale! Hot off the press! The Rookie's Guide to the Springfield Armory XD-S

    The Rookie’s Guide to the Springfield Armory XD-S

    $12.97 $4.99
    Add to cart
  • Sale! The Constitution - A Revolutionary Story

    The Constitution – A Revolutionary Story

    $16.99 $12.95
    Add to cart

Related Products

Dale Fricke Holsters Dale Fricke Seraphim Rmr Holster
$69.99 26% Off
Sticky Holsters Inside-the-Waistband Holster (MEDIUM)
$29.99
Crimson Trace LaserGrip for S&W J Frame LG-105
$208.99
Sticky Holsters IWB/Pocket Black Ambidextrous Holster
$26.95
Crimson Trace fits Glock G-Series- 29 & 30 - Lasergrip, Rear Activation LG-629
$199.00

Most Popular

  • Mil-Dot Made Easy
    Mil-Dot Made Easy
  • The 5 Best Pocket Carry Handguns
    The 5 Best Pocket Carry Handguns
  • 8 Shooting Tips: How Not To Look Like An Amateur Shooter
    8 Shooting Tips: How Not To Look Like An Amateur Shooter
  • Choosing Ammunition for the Springfield Armory XD-S & Other Short Barrel Handguns
    Choosing Ammunition for the Springfield Armory XD-S & Other Short Barrel Handguns
  • How (Not) to Install an AR-15 Flat Top Gas Block and Front Sight Base
    How (Not) to Install an AR-15 Flat Top Gas Block and Front Sight Base

Looking for a product you’ve seen here?

About Tom McHale…

Hello, my name is Tom McHale. I'm the creator and primary author of the Insanely Practical Guides series of how-to books.

I also write lot's of articles for various shooting related magazines and websites. You'll find my work at Shooting Illustrated, Concealed Carry Magazine, Tactical Retailer Magazine, Beretta USA, OutdoorHub, GunsAmerica, American Handgunner Magazine, Bearing Arms, AmmoLand, The National Shooting Sports Foundation, Grand View Outdoors, and Shooting Sports Retailer Magazine.

I help explain complicated things in a fun and easy-to-understand way. I believe that things don't have to be so complicated, although I suppose excessive techno-jargon keeps lots of well-intentioned lawyers in business.

If you want to learn about the world of guns, shooting and the American way, check out some of my books. Have a laugh or two.

Amazon Author Profile

LinkedIn

Google

Archives

Shooting Tips

  • Competitive Shooting
  • Concealed Carry
  • General Tips
  • Gun Maintenance & Customization
  • Gun Safety
  • Home Defense
  • Reloading

Guns

  • Handguns
  • Rifles
  • Shotguns

Gear

  • Holsters
  • Optics, Sights and Lasers
  • Reloading
  • Accessories

News

  • 2nd Amendment
  • Business
  • Crime
  • Politics
  • NRA Annual Meeting
  • SHOT Show

Reviews

  • Ammunition Reviews
  • Book Reviews
  • Clothing Bling Reviews
  • Gun Accessories Reviews
  • Gun Reviews
  • Holster Reviews
  • Optics and Sights Reviews
  • Reloading Equipment Reviews

Privacy Policy and Legal Disclosures | Copyright © 2018 My Gun Culture · Log in